• Award
  • Campaigns & Issues
  • Education
  • Eastern Ghats
  • Fifth Schedule
  • Forest Rights
  • Important Judgement
  • Legal Intervention
  • Samata Judgement
  • Mining
  • About Us
  • Covid-19

SAMATA

  • Home
  • Activities
  • Resources
    • Publications
    • Reports
    • Profile
    • Fellowship
    • Lectures & Speeches
    • Select Parliament Questions
    • Video
  • Migration
  • News
    • Newsletter – Samata
    • News at Glance
    • Dhimsa Magazine
    • Newsletter (MICI)
  • MICI
    • About MICI
    • Resources (MICI)
      • Law, Orders (CIC) & Judgements
      • Maps/Images
      • Newsletter (MICI)
      • Factsheet
      • Templates & Others
      • Parliament Questions
      • Reports & Documents
      • Minerals
      • Human Rights Bulletins
      • Status
      • Statistics
    • Institutions (MICI)
      • MoM Committees
      • MoEF
      • SEAC/SEIAA
      • CAG
      • DMGs
      • Notifications
    • Gallery (MICI)
    • News (MICI)
    • Important Link
  • Contact
DonateNow

Balco divestment controversy rages on

by Samata / Tuesday, 06 March 2001 / Published in News, Samata in News

Business Standars Economy Bureau, Rediff.com, March 6, 2001

The controversy of tribal land being sold to non-tribals in the Bharat Aluminium Company (Balco) privatisation deal remains unresolved. The controversy was raked up by Chhatisgarh Chief Minister Ajit Jogi and the workers union soon after the deal was announced.

The Chhatisgarh government had filed a petition in the high court, on the basis of the Samata (it is a non-governmental organisation) judgement of the Supreme Court, opposing the Balco divestment deal. The state government had stated that as the land on which the company’s Korba plant stands is ‘tribal land’, the Centre cannot transfer it to a private company.

The labour unions have been on strike over the issue since Saturday. The case has now been transferred to the Supreme Court.

In its 1997 Samata judgment, the apex court had prohibited the transfer of land and mining leases in scheduled areas of Andhra Pradesh (AP) to any non-tribal individual or entity. In case of Balco, the Bodai-Daldali mines in the Kawardha district and the plant in Korba fall under the scheduled areas of the erstwhile Madhya Pradesh (MP).

Following the judgements, ministry of tribal affairs sent letters to the state governments asking them to implement the judgement. However, most of the states including Madhya Pradesh or Chhatisgarh having notified scheduled areas are yet to implement the order.

Legal experts clarified that the apex court’s judgement was based on specific amendments introduced by the Andhra government in the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957 (MMDRA).

The state government had made a local amendment by inserting a section 11(5) to the Mines Act, which provides that no prospecting licence or mining lease shall be granted in the scheduled area of Andhra Pradesh to any person who is not a member of scheduled tribes.

In addition, the state government had notified the Andhra Pradesh Scheduled Area Transfer Regulation, 1959, which put restrictions on the transfer of lands in the scheduled areas to non-tribals.

In the Samata judgement, the apex court had interpreted the local amendment to the MMDRA and the scheduled area regulations and prohibited the transfer of land and of mining leases in scheduled areas of AP to any non-tribal individual or entity.

However, in case of BALCO, while certain areas fall under the scheduled areas list, neither MP nor Chhatisgarh have made any local amendments to the MMDRA prohibiting the grant of mining leases in scheduled areas to non-tribals, say officials sources.

Also, in the present transaction, the aluminium company is not transferring it’s rights or mining leases to a third party.

After divestment, the company, as an entity remains the same. It is not more ‘non-tribal’ than before, they add.

Powered by

Related

  • Tweet

About Samata

What you can read next

Samatha has been conferred the Lakshmipat Singhania – IIM, Lucknow National Leadership Awards 2008 under the Young Leaders Category in Community Service and Social Upliftment…
Orissa Allows Mining Projects In Tribal Areas
Row over tribal land acquisition by NMDC

Sidebar

  • Samata in News
  • News
  • Covid-19
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy

Select Categories

Archives page

Samata

We are a social justice organization working for the rights of the tribal “Adivasi” people of Andhra Pradesh, India and for the protection of the natural resources and ecology of the Eastern Ghats (hills).

more about Samata

Get involved

  • Samata in News
  • News
  • Covid-19
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy

Samata Judgement

Samata Vs. State of Andhra Pradesh (11.07.1997)

Read Judgement

©1990-2020 Samata || All Rights Reserved || Designed by B. P. Yadav

TOP